If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Yeah--I recorded this for the other half of the duet to pratice to! The finished version will def have BU vox...
thx for your kind words--God Bless!
trent
Leave a comment:
Guest replied
Trent, being a keys player myself, I love the keys on the 2nd version... sounds beautiful... I did definitely miss the BGV's though, especially on the chorus.
What you are doing on the keys through the verses definitely makes it sounds somewhat "Christmasy" which I think was the original intent of this song right?
Great work!
Leave a comment:
Guest replied
I still like it.....I really don't have a lot of experience to critique....but for someone who just loves music....I do like it a lot!
Maybe 5 years ago I would have given up on a song because it was similar to another, but I just hear way too many songs that are similar to each other to let it bother me anymore.
That's a really good point. I don't know how many songs I've given up on before I even really gave them a chance because some amazing writer somewhere already wrote on the subject. As a result I have very, very few songs written If we want a song that has no similarities to anything else in content and style we might as well just give up! BTW, I love the Once soundtrack.
Leave a comment:
Guest replied
@Trent: I agree with your comments. So you said "yaaaay"... do I win a prize or something? Ha ha
Russ--why "violent love"? I see God's love as "violent" on several levels--if it is true that "none seeks after God" (Rom. 3) and that the heart of man is "desperately wicked" then God's love must be nothing less than an arresting force to reach us. Also--the means of our redemption was nothing short of barbaric...the word "violent" is a reference to that as well. Overall the lyric of the song is simple and I don't want people to gloss over some nice words and say "endless love" or something else that's warm and fuzzy. I mean to kindly knock them over the head with the facts. I guess I'm a little violent too.
@Pianodude--yaaay! I was hoping someone would hear the similarity. I didn't try to mimic "Falling Slowly." I did realize part way through that there was an influence there, so I took deliberate measures to not use exactly the melody or chord pattern. Maybe 5 years ago I would have given up on a song because it was similar to another, but I just hear way too many songs that are similar to each other to let it bother me anymore. We could all list MANY examples. In fact, a publisher I talked to yesterday said he recognized the similarity in vibe and thought it was a good thing--that I should be careful not to lose that when recording it.
Could you elaborate a little bit on your choice of "violent" love in the prechorus? I love the lyric, I'm just curious to hear your thoughts behind using it.
Great song. Tells the reason for the Christmas story, not just the sentimental part.
Thanks for sharing it with us.
Tom
Leave a comment:
Guest replied
@Trent: Love it dude!
I do have to be honest with you about one things... many aspects of the chorus vocally remind me of "Falling Slowly" performed Glen Hansard and Marketa Irglova in the movie "Once".
The vocals (bgv included) on the beginning of your chorus, especially... remind me of the "take this sinking boat and point it home". Notice I said "reminded" me of ;-)
Beautiful song though!
Leave a comment:
Guest replied
That is a beautiful song! The words are so simple, but they are really beautifully simple if that makes sense. I love the melody too! Really nice!
Hey guys--here's the first version of a new cross-centered Christmas tune I wrote this last week. Not sure on groove yet--could go a little faster and be similar groove to "Sweetly Broken," but I don't want to drive too much and lose the vibe.
Leave a comment: