Nick,
The tune you're thinking of is called "Regent Square".
If you're looking for more modern hymn tunes, you can check the metrical index on my site psalmsandhymns.com. I've got Indelible Grace and Red Mountain Church hymns indexed there as well as my own hymn tunes.
Meter | Psalms and Hymns.com
I count 4 tunes with the meter that you're looking for.
You could also check out
Hymnary.org: a comprehensive index of hymns and hymnals | Hymnary.org and search by meter. That site is run by the Calvin Institute of Christian Worship.