Father Forgive Me, For I Have Sinned: One Man’s Journey to Restoration (Part 1)

November 2, 2009

man_praying(Publisher’s Note: Dear readers, I’m excited about this series, “Forgive Me Father, For I Have Sinned”. It’s written from the painful experience of a true brother who has walked the road of sin, shame, and restoration. When “TheWorshipCommunity.Com” launched, Ben Harrell (aka “el ben”) was one of our most active participants. I had the honor of being in the same church with him, sharing a place on staff with him, and calling him a friend. Though not as closely as I could have been, I’ve walked with him through the last year, always calling him a friend and brother. This series has everything to do with worship, with life, with ministry, and our walk with Christ. My hope and prayer is that the series will bring healing to those who have walked in Ben’s shoes, and will bring a warning to those who are playing with the fire of temptation and sin. If this series resonates with you, please comment and join the discussion. If you need prayer, counsel, accountability, or confidential ministry, please contact us and we’ll do our best to direct you to the best, safe place. For all of us have sinned, and fallen short of God’s glory.)

Part One: The Fall

I braced myself against my car door, the hot May air so thick, I could almost choke on it. I don’t think I had ever felt so disgusted with myself. A sudden realization of just how far I had gone washed over me and I threw up all over the ground next to my car. I wiped my mouth, took a ragged breath, and climbed in my car. I was barely out of the driveway before I texted “911” to my friend, Clint. It was our code, our “you need to call me because I’m about to screw up big time” code. Too late for that, I guess.

He called me less than a minute after I sent the text.

“What’s up?”

“Clint,” I choked, hot tears running down my cheeks, “I just screwed up bad, man.”

But I should start at the beginning.

This story takes its roots two years and a few months earlier. I was traveling with the worship team that was sent out from the school of ministry I went to, playing keys and helping lead worship with my classmates. We ended up on Saint Simons Island, a beautiful jewel of a place located on the southeastern coast of Georgia. It was a special trip for me because I used to vacation there with my parents when I was a kid. It was there that I first encountered Christian Renewal Church of Saint Simons Island.

CRCSSI was a church plant of a larger mother church in Brunswick, GA, a church that had really pioneered modern worship in the area, and it had some of the most hungry, passionate worshippers I’d come across in a long time. I fell in love with the place immediately. Then I met the pastor, Dan Harris, one of the nicest guys you’ll ever hope to meet. I felt an instant connection with him. Toward the end of the trip, he approached me about coming on staff as the youth pastor, and to say I was excited would be an understatement.

I was a 21-year-old ministry school grad with lots of passion and lots of ideas for shaking things up, and I was being given an opportunity to fulfill the dream I’d had since being called to ministry at 16.

I jumped in with both feet.

Three months into my first year, the worship pastor at CRCSSI, an amazing, talented, wonderful guy named Fred McKinnon (who later founded this website), was led to resign from his position, which left me in the dual role of youth pastor/worship leader, the two-for-one gig occupied by many of you reading these words right now. Truth be told, it was my first time leading worship for an entire church by myself. I honestly didn’t think I was that good those first few Sundays, but everyone was so encouraging, and I could feel myself beginning to grow in my gifting. I was blossoming.

Doors started opening with the local community of musicians and I started being asked to lead worship for local events, and I developed a reputation in the area for being something of a “young gun.” It was all very flattering.

This continued for a year, and then the novelty wore off. I had to face the music (no pun intended): my youth ministry was an afterthought to me and a source of frustration to my pastor, I had grown cocky and arrogant, and worse, my relationship with God had mellowed from a white-hot ache to know Him more to more of a dull throb in the back of my mind. I’d like to re-emphasize that my relationship with God wasn’t non-existent…just mediocre.

That was when the porn started. At first, it was a screw-up here and there, but then it grew until I knew I had to address it. I confessed to Clint, and we both got the accountability software from XXXchurch.com, and I took a deep breath and told myself I was over it. Four months later, I found myself in a totally inappropriate position with a totally inappropriate person, crossing lines that I swore I’d never cross, all for a brief moment of pleasure.

That’s where I ended up losing my lunch on the pavement and calling Clint.

I told him the whole story, sparing none of the embarrassing details. He sat quietly on the other end for a while.

“What am I going to do, Clint?” I asked him, already knowing what I had to do, “if I confess to this, they’ll fire me.”

“Ben, I can’t tell you what to do,” he said with a deep sigh, “you’re going to have to make that decision yourself, but I do know this: what you do now will determine who you’ll be for the rest of your life.”

I won’t lie, I’m a schemer and a dreamer by nature. I already had three or four strategies for making this thing go away, and none of them required me to confess. Then I thought of what it would be like to live with myself.

I didn’t even get through praying for it. That evening in my home, the dialogue between me and God went something like this:

“God, what should I…”

“Confess.”

“That’s just my guilty conscience talking. Deep breath. Okay, now really. What should I…”

“Confess your sins one to another so that you may be healed.”

“I know that’s what your word says, but…”

“Confess, Ben.”

“I don’t want to lose my job.”

“I’m your provider.”

“I don’t want to be hurt.”

“I’m your healer.”

“Okay, Lord. Fine.”

I called Clint with my intentions, and the next morning, I walked into my pastor’s office after staff meeting and spilled my guts about the porn, my struggle with it, the situation the day before, the whole nine. He was very gracious, thanked me for confessing to him, prayed with me, and told me he’d get back with me. I walked out of his office feeling like a weight had been lifted off my shoulders.

Little did I know that the worst was yet to come…

Next Week’s Part 2: Rock Bottom

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Live
  • MySpace
  • Ping.fm
  • Pownce
  • Slashdot
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Tumblr
  • TwitThis

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

Related posts:

  1. Father Forgive Me, For I Have Sinned Part II
  2. Zero Tolerance
  3. Dealing With Tech Arts Burnout, Part 2
  4. Perspective

Comments



  1. twc_admin's Avatar twc_admin says:

    Ben,
    Thanks a million for posting this - I admire your willingness to be vulnerable and to share your story.

    I believe this will resonate with many, many people. I'm sure there will be those who read this and realize their own need for help. I hope this community can be a place of such help, accountability, and hope.

    It's a sad, sad state when we're afraid to confess our weaknesses, temptations, and struggles because we fear we'd lose our jobs. God help us. But it is so very true.

    Look forward to the conversation, and to Part 2 and the ongoing series.

  2. skyescraper's Avatar skyescraper says:

    Thanks so much Ben for being honest. I appreciate your openness and your vulnerability.

  3. Smitty's Avatar Smitty says:

    Thanks Ben...I really admire your courage and willingness to be broken, not just before God, but your peers as well...You are a class act, believe it or not.

    This addiction, or temptation, is one that most men have to deal with at one time or another. I have, and many of my friends have as well.

    I'm looking forward to reading the rest, and learning more about someone I'd proudly call a friend and brother in Christ.

    Smitty

  4. Ben: Thank you so much for your strength and honesty to tell this story. I know from experience that the spiritual life of a worship leader (or really anyone in ministry) is a rocky one. I praise God that he is restoring and healing you! And I look forward to reading more from you.

  5. twc_admin's Avatar twc_admin says:

    What do ya'll think the solution should be - when we are struggling with something, but we're afraid to confess our weaknesses out of fear for losing our job.

    Granted, leaders are held to a higher standard ... and they should be. But, just because we're struggling with something ... does that mean we should be removed from our position of leadership and ministry?

    I know there's no easy answer for that, and every case is different - but I'd love your thoughts.

  6. milepost13's Avatar milepost13 says:

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by twc_admin View Post
    What do ya'll think the solution should be - when we are struggling with something, but we're afraid to confess our weaknesses out of fear for losing our job.

    Granted, leaders are held to a higher standard ... and they should be. But, just because we're struggling with something ... does that mean we should be removed from our position of leadership and ministry?

    I know there's no easy answer for that, and every case is different - but I'd love your thoughts.
    it's one thing to light the fuse and then ask for help in putting it out. It's another to light the fuse and wait for the explosion until asking for help (or being caught). Each of us light fuses in our lives, probably every day...I for one am much more ready to show compassion to those who recognize their personal fuses and reach out for help.

    Nate

  7. Smitty's Avatar Smitty says:

    I'M with Nate...I would be much more inclined to extend the the same grace and forgiveness that was shown to me.

    Smitty

  8. windbag's Avatar windbag says:

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by twc_admin View Post
    ... and they should be. But, just because we're struggling with something ... does that mean we should be removed from our position of leadership and ministry?

    I know there's no easy answer for that, and every case is different - but I'd love your thoughts.
    I watched people walk away from the church and their faith when one pastor took it upon himself to be judge, jury, and executioner in their lives. They had confessed and repented of some sin in their lives, but he demanded they be punished.

    King David didn't get removed--even for a season--because of his sin, nor did he undergo counseling and await someone's approval after a sufficient amount of time had transpired before being returned to his position as king and nationally-known worship leader. He confessed, repented, and moved on.

    I do not think that we should remove people from their positions if they have confessed, repented, and demonstrate victorious restraint in the area where they fell. I do think that removal is appropriate if a) they refuse to call sin sin, b) they don't repent of it, or c) they return to it.

  9. skyescraper's Avatar skyescraper says:

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by windbag View Post
    I do not think that we should remove people from their positions if they have confessed, repented, and demonstrate victorious restraint in the area where they fell. I do think that removal is appropriate if a) they refuse to call sin sin, b) they don't repent of it, or c) they return to it.
    Well said.

  10. Smitty's Avatar Smitty says:

    Yup.

    Smitty

  11. Quote:
    Originally Posted by twc_admin View Post
    What do ya'll think the solution should be - when we are struggling with something, but we're afraid to confess our weaknesses out of fear for losing our job.

    Granted, leaders are held to a higher standard ... and they should be. But, just because we're struggling with something ... does that mean we should be removed from our position of leadership and ministry?

    I know there's no easy answer for that, and every case is different - but I'd love your thoughts.
    I agree in principle with what most of you have said, but the simple truth is that a person who publicly confesses a great moral failure, loses the respect of many of those who previously respected him (or her), and it becomes impossible to minister effectively.

    It is sad that forgiveness among Christians is incomplete forgiveness (unlike God's forgiveness), but, unlike God, we cannot bury what we know in the sea of forgetfulness.

    So when one of us finds ourself in the author's place, (God forbid) we need to be prepared for the necessity of moving on to somewhere else.

  12. On another note, those of you who went through the Pure Praise study last year, and posted on the Pure Praise blog on this site, may recall me saying that I had traveled some awful paths, and that God was making me into a new creation... I think Ben is telling my story.

  13. twc_admin's Avatar twc_admin says:

    I think there is some truth there, but I don't necessarily think you lose all respect.

    I think you lose all respect when you lie, cheat, and get caught.

    I think when you man up, confess, stand before people and say "I've sinned, I've failed you, I'm sorry, and I'm getting help" ... the DISAPPOINTMENT is there, but the RESPECT goes up ... at least, with me!

  14. El Ben's Avatar El Ben says:

    Quote:
    I agree in principle with what most of you have said, but the simple truth is that a person who publicly confesses a great moral failure, loses the respect of many of those who previously respected him (or her), and it becomes impossible to minister effectively.

    I don't think the truth is quite that simple. Everyone I've confessed to say they respect me more, and as for effective ministry, I don't think the context of effective ministry is dependent on our standing with people, and I certainly don't think that my failure or my confession makes effective ministry impossible for me.

    Thanks for commenting, though.

  15. Thank you Ben. Blessings from a fellow bumbler who knows God's grace.

  16. merry's Avatar merry says:

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Wannabe a Worshiper View Post
    It is sad that forgiveness among Christians is incomplete forgiveness (unlike God's forgiveness), but, unlike God, we cannot bury what we know in the sea of forgetfulness.
    Is that something we should be trying to teach people then? Obviously, we don't have the physical ability to forget what people have done. But should we say that because other people can't forgive as God forgives, that a person should be removed from a position even though he is repentant?

    I'm not trying to be argumentative as I'm trying to express things I've been thinking about with situations around me recently. What an opportunity to display God's grace!

  17. ClaytonR's Avatar ClaytonR says:

    This message is timely for many.
    Thank you so much for sharing. I can't wait to read the rest!

  18. Chris Fry's Avatar Chris Fry says:

    This is definately something of which I believe more is needed! one of the greatest failings of the church is that many of us do not fully understand the concept of forgiveness and restoration.

    When is the next instalment coming?

(18) comments | Add your comments

Twitter links powered by Tweet This v1.5.3, a WordPress plugin for Twitter.